Perfected Yorkshire Puddings

Yorkshire puddings

This staple part of the British Sunday roast was traditionally served before the main dinner as a cheap way of filling tummies before moving on to the more expensive meat and vegetables. Yorkshire puddings, or variations on them, are eaten around the world, Americans have their own version called popovers which are often eaten with sweet toppings, or served with meat like we do.

The basic recipe is of course very simple, but getting it right so that they rise well isn’t as straightforward. There is general consensus that the batter needs to be cold and the fat needs to be very hot, but beyond that, there are differences of opinion on the proportions of ingredients and methods for preparation.

I’ve tried different ways over the years, with varying success, but I have now perfected the method that consistently works best for me. The batter came half way up inside those muffin tins, and you can see how much they’ve risen up above that.


– 140g plain white flour
– 3 eggs plus one egg white
– 200ml milk
– 1/2 teaspoon salt
– Vegetable oil or meat fat drippings for cooking


1.Β Whisk eggs and egg white together with an electric whisk for one minute.

2. Add flour a couple of tablespoons at a time whisking in between.

3. Add milk, whisk for another minute. Pour the batter into a jug and leave in the fridge until you’re ready to use.

4. Put a little oil and/or meat fat drippings into the bottom of a 12 hole muffin tin. Place into a hot oven 230C/450F for about 10 minutes.

5. Remove the muffin tin from the oven and quickly pour the batter into the muffin holes, about half way up each one, and put it back into the oven straight away.

6. Leave to cook for about 20 minutes until well risen and golden brown. It’s really important not to open the oven while they are cooking. This can be inconvenient if you want to get your meat out 10 minutes before serving to leave it to rest and carve, so if you have a separate small oven, cook the Yorkshires in there instead.

You can actually cook these ahead of time and freeze them once cooked. They can then be reheated in a hot oven for about 4 minutes from frozen. They’re not quite as nice as freshly made, but they’re still pretty good that way!



27 responses to “Perfected Yorkshire Puddings

  1. So that’s how genuine British Yorkshire pudding is supposed to be made! This friend of mine who cooked a lot when I was growing up had a recipe and made Yorkshire pudding, but it wasn’t like that at all. She made a pot roast in the oven and then dropped the batter directly into the pan around the roast when it was pretty much done. That’s really more like a dumpling, I guess. But it was really good! And popovers were something I heard about but have never eaten.


    • This isn’t the most traditional method, certainly not in the way I’ve made the batter, generally the eggs aren’t whisked separately first, they’re beaten into the flour, but this way works best for me! The traditional cooking method involved the meat being cooked on a rack in the oven, and the fat was collected in a tray underneath, and the batter would be poured into that tray underneath, so perhaps your friend’s method yielded similar results to that. Cooking individual ones is a more recent way of doing it, but a lot of people still prefer to make one big one and cut it into wedges.


    • It’s definitely a simple recipe, but over the years I’ve had times where they’ve risen, and times where they haven’t, and I could never work out why, so this way I discovered of whisking the eggs first (which isn’t the most usual way), seems to work well every time, also this recipe has more eggs in it than the way I used to do, so I think that helps too! We do love Yorkshire Puddings with our roast dinners over here πŸ™‚


  2. I haven’t enjoyed Yorkshire Pudding in y.e.a.r.s.
    As I read #5, I recalled one time I put the Muffin tin into the hot oven and took it out wearing oven mitts. I poured in the batter and forgot to put the oven mitts back on. Yes. I burned the tips of all my fingers. Can’t recall if I made the Pudding again after that. πŸ˜€


  3. I read a mystery where a cook was devastated that her locally famous Yorkshire puddings hadn’t risen properlyβ€”not just once, but three times! So I’ve always imagined that they’re not easy to do. πŸ™‚


    • Yes it’s funny, they’re one of those things which in theory are really simple, but sometimes they just don’t rise even though you think you did exactly the same as last time! This method seems a bit more foolproof (although these could very well fail on me sometime too!).


  4. One of my favorite childhood meals is roast and Yorkshire pudding that my dad made. He is from England, so he pretty much prepared it the way you do. I have made it too, but still can’t beat my dads recipe.


    • Oh yes I forgot you had that English connection. I wondered after I published this post, and seeing that a couple of commenters hadn’t really been sure what they were, whether some people might think you have them on the side, like bread, rather than actually on the plate with the meat and veg and gravy!


This is where you get a chance to speak, be sweet now...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s